Photo array lineup vs in person lineup

The collaborative research initiative between researchers and law enforcement communities will be challenging as it will necessitate 1 standardized police procedures; 7 2 systematic valid evidence collection and data entry and analysis; and 3 education and training for both researchers and law enforcement professionals on the differences between these two communities in their use of terms and considerations of standards of evidence and uncertainties in data.

Mason's identifications had an independent, reliable basis. The descriptions of prior identifications and confidence at the time of those earlier out-of-court identifications provide more useful information to the fact-finders and decision-makers.

This fact causes us to question the reliability of the identification, particularly since a number of cases seem to indicate that a witness who is presented with a photo array containing multiple photographs of a defendant will generally identify the defendant in each of the recurring pictures.

The absence of such specific findings by the trial court "unduly complicates appellate review.

Looking for other ways to read this?

Brathwaite, supra, U. Hopefully this apparent fundamental flaw in the conception of this pilot project is either a reporting mistake, or if an actual reflection of the intended assessment metric, will be cured before the first the first tax dollar is wasted.

The understanding derived from basic research includes principles that enable one to predict how a system such as vision or memory might behave under specific conditions such as those associated with witnessing a crimeand to identify the conditions under which it will operate most effectively and those under which it will fail.

Therefore, the use of showups should be secondary in preference to the use of photo arrays or lineups when possible. The committee recommends that local jurisdictions make efforts to ensure that defendants receive funding to obtain access to qualified experts.

Immediately thereafter, the shortest and most light-skinned[2] of the three males approached Ms. Citing fiscal implications, CCM urges the Committee to obtain a fiscal note prior to taking any action on it. In addition to instruction at the police academy, officers should receive periodic refresher training, and officers assigned to investigative units should receive in-depth instruction.

Carefully document a witness' response before any feedback from law enforcement; Avoid multiple identification procedures in which a witness views the same suspect more than once. Findings and Recommendations Eyewitnesses make mistakes. Rodney Ellis, D-Houston, who unsuccessfully tried to get the state Legislature to set up a working group to come up with a model policy for lineup procedures.

Like the New Jersey instructions, 6 the instructions should allow judges to focus on factors relevant to the specific case, since not all cases implicate the same factors.


Division of Criminal Justice: Mason then was shown two albums that contained approximately thirty-eight color photographs. Before he viewed the pictures, he was informed that "there were detectives from Philadelphia who had photographs of a man who they might believe was the man who held us up.


The committee recommends blind double-blind or blinded administration of both photo arrays and live lineups and the adoption of clear, written policies and training on photo array and live lineup administration. While some states have made minor changes to the due process framework, e.

State v. Madison

II The United States Supreme Court has long expressed its concerns regarding the unreliability of eyewitness identification. If practical, and if the witness has not refused, the area where the lineup is conducted will be audio and video recorded to document the lineup, the eyewitness, and all statements made by the eyewitness.

He stated that the entire robbery took approximately ten to fifteen minutes. Appellant claimed that he had come to J. The Appellate Division thus concluded that the trial court properly admitted both Mr. Mason's description was, according to him, an accurate representation of the man who held a gun to his head.

He was sentenced to months in prison, a triple upward durational departure. Police officers should be trained to ask open-ended questions, avoid suggestiveness, and efficiently manage scenes with multiple witnesses e.

The trial court did not err in refusing to allow cross-examination because there was no foundation in the record supporting J. If necessary, a showup should happen as soon as possible after the incident.

Is the man in that picture the man who held the gun to your head and robbed you that night. Appellant's constitutional rights were not violated and the trial court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to allow appellant to cross-examine J.

For example, the knowledge and skills from training can be applied to other issues that personnel face, either in forensic science technologies or in process administration, evaluation, and quality improvement.

Showups, Lineups, and Photo Arrays

That statute and rule generally bar evidence of a rape victim's sexual history. Each witness shall perform the identification procedures without any other witness present. Each folder contained eight pictures.

Appellant was charged with multiple counts of criminal sexual conduct. It must be recognized that improper employment of photographs by police may sometimes cause witnesses to err in identifying criminals. Eyewitness Identification: Simultaneous vs. Sequential Lineups. Most U.S. law enforcement agencies use the simultaneous lineup, in which the eyewitness views a lineup of individuals or a photo array; that is, all individuals are viewed at the same time.

that the photographs and/or audio/video recording of the lineup required by this directive were taken and the name rank and star of the person taking the photographs or audio/video recording, and for a photo lineup, the CHRIS photo array number and the name, rank and star of the person inventorying the photo lineup.

Marvin Anderson was the only person in the lineup whose picture was in the original photo array shown to the victim.

There was a problem providing the content you requested

She identified him in the lineup as well. I observed this person engaged in this kind of activity," said Turner. To show how reliable or unreliable photo line-ups are, WREG asked the University of Memphis Criminal Justice Club to help.

Photo Lineup. A presentation of photographs to a victim or witness of a crime. A photo lineup, also known as a photo array and or photo display, is a procedure used by law enforcement personnel to discover or confirm the identity of a criminal suspect.

Computerised photo-lineup presentation can ensure that witnesses do not miss the important instruction that the culprit may or may not be in the array.

Photo array lineup vs in person lineup
Rated 5/5 based on 57 review
What is a Photo Lineup? (with pictures)